By Scott Yates, Wheat Life, Washington Grain Commission
By the time you read this, Eastern Washington will either be in the midst of one of the worst stripe rust epidemics in years—or not.
By the time you read this, farmers will have either tank mixed a fungicide in with their spring herbicide application— or not.
By the time you read this Xianming Chen, Agricultural Research Service scientist and national rust expert, will either be basking in a glow of vindication for his mathematical- based stripe rust model forecast—or not.
Let’s back up. On March 4, Chen reported finding stripe rust in a field near Walla Walla. That’s early. In three of the last five years, rust didn’t show up around the southeast Washington community until late April. The early appearance of the disease along the state’s southern border, combined with a relatively mild winter and an early warm up, has Chen estimating losses on stripe rust-susceptible wheat varieties could run as high as 60 percent without a fungicide spray. That’s about how bad stripe rust was in 2010 when Eastern Washington farmers spent $27 million on fungicide applications to save an estimated 13.7 million bushels of grain worth nearly $100 million.
It would not be inappropriate to call the Pacific Northwest (PNW) a stripe rust mecca. The first signs of Puccinia striiformis, known as yellow rust in many parts of the world, are usually found in the Willamette Valley of Oregon and Mt. Vernon in western Washington, both cool, moist locations where the disease is known to overwinter.
On the east side of the Cascades, however, rust can be killed out during cold winters, which is probably what happened in at least a portion of Washington during an unusual cold spell in the second week of November 2014. But in a good news/bad news scenario, the frigid temperatures killed a lot of wheat too. Where the weather didn’t get cold enough to kill rust, like around Walla Walla and further south into Oregon, the fungus hunkered down in winter wheat fields.
To spray or not to spray fungicides is the question, and there are different philosophies about preventative spraying versus waiting until stripe rust shows up in the field.
Although stripe rust likes rain and dew while it’s infecting plants, during its winter survival mode, dry weather doesn’t faze it. When the weather warms up above freezing, the fungus begins to produce yellow-orange pustules on wheat leaves. These features ultimately break open and release a mass of microscopic spores that can blow into the next field, the next state and perhaps even the next continent.
Chen uses mathematical models based on weather variables correlated with data on yield losses from stripe rust plot research going back more than three decades to come up with his forecasts. His loss estimates are based on susceptible varieties that aren’t sprayed.
Like the canary in the coal mine which once alerted miners to toxic gases when it keeled over, Chen’s forecast is meant to provide farmers a heads-up to the sort of conditions he believes they’ll face through the spring and summer growing season. Of course, what he can’t predict with any accuracy is how much rain will fall or how hot it will be, both variables that impact the virulence and spread of stripe rust. Which means his 60 percent loss number on susceptible varieties could be higher or lower.
“Such forecast values are caused by the unusually early and cold period in the second week of November and the unusually warm weather afterwards during the winter,” he said. “Although the cold period was widespread in the PNW, there were big variations in how cold.”
In the northern end of wheat production in Eastern Washington, it’s likely any reservoir of rust inoculum died, but under the right conditions, it will only take a few weeks for the windborne spores to travel from the south to re-infect the area again. That’s why Chen often recommends that farmers in the southern parts of the state begin to check their fields three to four weeks earlier in the spring than those in its more northern reaches.
“The amount of rust inoculum is determined by the acreage of susceptible versus resistant varieties, race groups and weather conditions,” Chen said, singling out several varieties widely grown around Walla Walla as not having adequate resistance under severe rust conditions. Unfortunately, even planting all resistant varieties wouldn’t eliminate the stripe rust reservoir since there are many grass hosts for the disease to survive on.
Like wheat prices, stripe rust also follows cycles. The biggest stripe rust epidemic in the state resulted from widespread planting of the club wheat, Omar, which was bred to resist smuts, not rust, and led to devastating stripe rust epidemics in 1960 and 1961. In 1981, another severe outbreak was caused by favorable weather conditions. Although there were some significant stripe rust outbreaks in the state in the 1990s, disease incidence was generally low because of the resistant cultivars being planted, particularly Madsen, which was released in 1988.
“Another factor that influenced stripe rust during the 1990s was that before 2000, spring wheat was grown on less acreage. As less resistant varieties of spring wheat increased in acreage, there were also increased opportunities for stripe rust fungal survival,” Chen said, adding that he hopes recently released spring cultivars with high levels of resistance, like Seahawk, will come to dominate spring acreage.
Mike Pumphrey, spring wheat breeder at Washington State University since 2010, said spring wheat stripe rust epidemics are more dependent upon each year’s weather than winter wheat. May and June rains—in fact rains all the way up to the Fourth of July—can create havoc in spring wheat.
“If I’m praying for good (stripe rust) screening for my program, I want nothing more than a 65 degree day and rain on the Fourth of July. If I get that, the rust explodes on spring wheat,” he said, adding that hot weather doesn’t appear to shut down spore propagation for newer races like it used to. “I think water is the biggest factor.”
The 2010 spring wheat crop came in at a respectable 52 bushels an acre average across the region, but the yield was achieved by the widespread application of fungicides. Even then, Pumphrey believes the crop lost a tremendous amount of potential due to the year’s widespread rust infection.
“Losses for spring wheat were severely underestimated that year,” he said. “But growers got a wake-up call from the experience having seen the data from their own farms and elsewhere that they need to be vigilant.” In 2011, another bad stripe rust year, spring wheat yields increased to 62 bushels an acre.
The headache for breeders like Pumphrey is that wheat varieties which once had their resistance compromised by a new rust race might wind up being resistant to an older race that returns and dominants a particular year. That may inadvertently wind up benefiting farmers, but it presents a conundrum for the breeder who’s left to guess at what he’s dealing with.
“It makes breeding hard because breeders are trying to select material that is not going up and down depending on the races in a region. You give me four or five good resistance genes that don’t change with the weather and are effective and I’m good,” he said.
Only Pumphrey wants the right combination of genes because along with protecting the plant from stripe rust, they may also exert a yield drag. In the developing world where single varieties are used for long stretches of time and money for chemical applications are scarce, that’s a feasible approach, but in the Northwest, even a 5 percent yield drag costs a farmer far more than applying fungicide does.