While some may be mulling over the possibility of narrow-row strip-tilling, no-tiller Joe Breker of Havana, N.D., decided to jot down on paper both the pros and the cons.
PROS:
-
Warmer soil temperatures at no-till planting time.
-
Mellow seedbed.
-
Lessens need for fertilizer on the no-till drill or planter.
-
Can use anhydrous ammonia if applied in the fall.
-
Excellent fertilizer placement.
-
Removes residue from the row.
-
Allows earlier no-till planting.
-
Allows some work to be done in the fall.
-
Allows no-tilling of row crops in northern latitudes.
-
Narrow rows compete with weeds better.
-
Narrow rows have potential for higher no-till yields.
CONS:
-
May require additional equipment.
-
Window for application is sometimes narrow.
-
Do not always have proper soil conditions for fertilizer application.
-
Sometimes soil is too mellow for good no-till planter performance.
-
May be difficult to keep the no-till planter on the row in some conditions.
-
Equipment is more difficult to fit down narrow rows.
-
Crop may be susceptible to lodging at higher plant populations.
-
Equipment may be more expensive because of row width.