No-Till Not Phosphorus Culprit

As increased levels of dissolved phosphorus are identified as a major concern dealing with the increased algal blooms found in Lake Erie, some folks have been pointing a finger at no-till as the cause. Yet the facts regarding phosphorus runoff in the Western Lake Erie Basin watershed near Toledo, Ohio, don’t back up that argument.

“Sure, there is a lot of no-till planting in the watershed,” says Steve Davis, the National Resources Conservation Service (NRSC) watershed specialist at Lima, Ohio. “But the percentage of long-term continuous no-till is still small in this area.”

This watershed includes 4.9 million acres in northwest Ohio, northeast Indiana and southeast Michigan. In any given year, about 40% of the watershed has no form of conservation tillage or protective residue cover on the soil surface at planting time.

Tillage Worries

 Davis cites data from a recently completed 5-year study of the watershed to refute the claims against no-till.

While phosphorus can run off no-till fields, especially if it rains right after application, Davis says the same is true when phosphorus is applied to conventional- and minimum-tilled fields. He maintains several factors working together are more likely to explain the increase in levels of dissolved phosphorus runoff in Lake Erie:

  • Changes in the methods and timing of fertilizer applications.
  • Use of broadcast surface application vs. row-applied fertilizer.
  • Applying fertilizer during the winter on frozen ground.
  • Increased soil compaction concerns due to larger equipment.
  • A growing trend toward applying 2 years worth of fertilizer at one time…
To view the content, please subscribe or login.
 Premium content is for our Digital-only and Premium subscribers. A Print-only subscription doesn't qualify. Please purchase/upgrade a subscription with the Digital product to get access to all No-Till Farmer content and archives online. Learn more about the different versions and what is included.

Lessiter frank

Frank Lessiter

Frank Lessiter has served as editor of No-Till Farmer since the publication was launched in November of 1972. Raised on a six-generation Michigan Centennial Farm, he has spent his entire career in agricultural journalism. Lessiter is a dairy science graduate from Michigan State University.

Top Articles

Current Issue


No-Till Farmer

Get full access NOW to the most comprehensive, powerful and easy-to-use online resource for no-tillage practices. Just one good idea will pay for your subscription hundreds of times over.

Subscribe Now

View More

Must Read Free Eguides

Download these helpful knowledge building tools

View More
Top Directory Listings